Making the problem worse is that the whole idea of Genesis seems to have been inspired by Plato’s Timaeus. In other word, a human creation inspired by a Greek philosophy.
I keep hearing things like this, which remind me of an alt. Theory of biblical origin— where the Torah and hebrew scriptures were composed in Alexandria as a platonic artificial national-myth project, hoping to create a state aligned with The Republic.
I don’t necessarily believe this, but it’s a strange alignment with this anecdote.
Religion is anthropocentrism incarnate, and since we do not live in an anthropocentric universe, religion doesn't have a leg to stand on. Islam is going to be the last religion to get the memo, and it might have wiped us all out by then. Alas, the Abrahamic Cinematic Universe and its fanatical fanbase will have to be annihilated, physically and memetically. I have said this many times before, and will undoubtedly be saying it many times more. It's the only way.
I find that the general subtext of “science says what religion is…” to be appalling, irrelevant of whether or not creationism is a tenable or likely explanation for the origin of life. To say such a thing is basically a concession to materialism or some kind of dishonest “pantheism”, the same philosophies that were more or less instrumental in the exiling of tradition. Treating science or “nature” as a criteria for determining religion is deluded because its entirely consistent of descriptions for phenomena, outside of a more nuanced or philosophized definition of “nature”(which would just be the content of some such thing), nature has almost no normative power in determining what is transcendental or how to reach it. Spirituality and religion are concerned with the subtle elements of human existence, not the visceral. One contextualizes the other and I think you have it backwards. I think that it will always be a fools gambit to try and synthesize religion and science, and or to make metaphysics and science integrated in some holistic fashion, and this is because metaphysical inquiries always go beyond the limits of perception or descriptions of particulars. If you really believe this type of stuff, what grounds do you have to separate yourself from organized evil such as freemasonry or any of the other strange perennial deists and whatnot that feed upon the corpse of modern Christianity?
Sure, you can make this theological distinction between observation and meaning if you'd like, even though Christianity itself hinged solely upon such observations for a time (ie the empty tomb). The problem comes when we assume our observations of phenomena are consistent with the meanings we have developed for ourselves over the centuries, when in fact they do not. A good example mentioned here is the distinction of man from nature by kind rather than degree - this was central to the sense of meaning that propelled Faustian culture, but it just isn't true, and it was natural sciences that informed us of this, not a theologian. Even for St. Francis of Assisi, the best he could do was demand a wolf become a city-dwelling dog.
It's not difficult to find other examples where "visceral", evolutionary realities have always informed meaning and not the other way around, so I don't agree with this at all. Sexual roles/relationships and "pair bonding", kin selection, altruism, aggression, etc. A better argument would be that they are two sides of the same coin, which is the take you see the most in our culture downstream of the Anglo-American tradition. I'm really not even sure if Heidegger would agree with this, as Dasein concerns itself with visceral experiences.
It is as I feared then. The amalgamation of monistic mystics is what brought modernity to the scene. Rather confused by this article. It talks about this ontology not being a kind of pretty or glorified atheism, but it reduces mind to physical elements, denies things like volition, and supposes no liberation from the world, no real ethical reality aside from serving the will of “nature”(?).
It’s also odd that you mention non-duality, buddhism and platonism when these philosophies by and large qualify reality as immaterial and abstract, materiality or matter being a property or illusionary capacity of the spirit or ethereal. They are saying that the world is actually exclusively supernatural, and that nature is a reflective or accidental element. That is a radical departure from saying the world is material and that there is a kind of vital life force to things which is still inanimate, and that there’s no capacity for transcendence or victory over the world.
I think that this is rather confusing because I don’t see classical theism and atheism, or materialism and theism synthesized, more like materialism given enchantment. I have no idea how this will be a formative element of the new world religions or paganism considering that this sort of thing is already status quo for the intellectual powers that be, and has been for some time. Is there any kind of soteriological elements to this philosophy? And kind of proper view about what one is to do? I’m just not sure what a bunch of material facts have to do with religion, even if they’re considered eternal or are afforded an infinite return.
The things you're asking for are almost exclusively Christian in nature. Paganism is phenomenological. It is as it appears to a specific people, or rather a specific ecology. So no, it's not going to have soteriology or "liberation" - there's nothing to be saved from. There's no universal code of conduct - its not a universalist worldview.
Generally you seem to believe that meaning, "religion" has to be a set of metaphysical constructions, independent and superlative of nature. I'm saying that this distinction isn't necessary, and that the ordering is wrong. Observation precedes any and all rationalization. You have to first see red before you can internalize some emotional understanding of what red means. Again, you already DO this for virtually all of your sensibilities. Values of marriage, family, etc are all fundamentally rooted in nature, not because of a tandem orderly-reasoned-divine-nature, but because these things are quite literally intrinsic to our biological existence.
Paganism is, additionally, an experiential religion. As opposed to Revelation. It takes in its immediate surroundings, its conditions, and its relationships and develops its rituals, pantheons, and myths from here. You are correct in stating that the order is reversed, but only in relationship to Christianity. It's not paganism that is the inversion of the natural religiosity of man, it's not monism that has brought "modernity".
The point of this wasn't really to deal with specific arguments, as there's plenty of people making plenty of content against things like IC already. I'm dealing more with the general idea of macroevolution (the pejorative) here.
I don't agree that IC is the main argument against it anyways, because baraminology rarely differentiates its "kinds" based on IC, but reproductive barriers. I don't think Meyer would propose a string of IC proteins so separate cats from dogs - he's more worried about bacteria. Again, plenty of content there already.
By reconcile I mean explain. There are plenty of people who try to use science to explain miracles (see Turin Shroud "radioactive blast"). That very subversion of the order Christianity sought to maintain between it and science is really the point of this article.
I believe the current main argument against macroevolution is time - any proposed mechanism has tested to be magnitudes too slow to reflect any agreed upon timeline. As in any mutation fixation rate as proposed by neodarwinists would take 100x the time that anyone even supposes the earth was around for.
Secondly I think reconciling Christendom with science is easy. I believe human technology is just barely beginning to approach the things Christ did, which he said would happen. Simple cataract surgery can restore sight to the blind and current developments for sensors for the never-sighted are sound. Restoring rotted flesh is gonna be just a few jumps in paradigms away. And so on.
Very good!
Making the problem worse is that the whole idea of Genesis seems to have been inspired by Plato’s Timaeus. In other word, a human creation inspired by a Greek philosophy.
https://vridar.org/series-index/plato-and-the-biblical-creation-accounts-gmirkin/
I keep hearing things like this, which remind me of an alt. Theory of biblical origin— where the Torah and hebrew scriptures were composed in Alexandria as a platonic artificial national-myth project, hoping to create a state aligned with The Republic.
I don’t necessarily believe this, but it’s a strange alignment with this anecdote.
Religion is anthropocentrism incarnate, and since we do not live in an anthropocentric universe, religion doesn't have a leg to stand on. Islam is going to be the last religion to get the memo, and it might have wiped us all out by then. Alas, the Abrahamic Cinematic Universe and its fanatical fanbase will have to be annihilated, physically and memetically. I have said this many times before, and will undoubtedly be saying it many times more. It's the only way.
We will bury you.
We already buried you. Many times over, actually. I’ve only ever used these two arguments. No others are necessary.
https://infidels.org/library/modern/richard-schoenig-no-god/
https://infidels.org/library/modern/horia-plugaru-never-created/
I find that the general subtext of “science says what religion is…” to be appalling, irrelevant of whether or not creationism is a tenable or likely explanation for the origin of life. To say such a thing is basically a concession to materialism or some kind of dishonest “pantheism”, the same philosophies that were more or less instrumental in the exiling of tradition. Treating science or “nature” as a criteria for determining religion is deluded because its entirely consistent of descriptions for phenomena, outside of a more nuanced or philosophized definition of “nature”(which would just be the content of some such thing), nature has almost no normative power in determining what is transcendental or how to reach it. Spirituality and religion are concerned with the subtle elements of human existence, not the visceral. One contextualizes the other and I think you have it backwards. I think that it will always be a fools gambit to try and synthesize religion and science, and or to make metaphysics and science integrated in some holistic fashion, and this is because metaphysical inquiries always go beyond the limits of perception or descriptions of particulars. If you really believe this type of stuff, what grounds do you have to separate yourself from organized evil such as freemasonry or any of the other strange perennial deists and whatnot that feed upon the corpse of modern Christianity?
Sure, you can make this theological distinction between observation and meaning if you'd like, even though Christianity itself hinged solely upon such observations for a time (ie the empty tomb). The problem comes when we assume our observations of phenomena are consistent with the meanings we have developed for ourselves over the centuries, when in fact they do not. A good example mentioned here is the distinction of man from nature by kind rather than degree - this was central to the sense of meaning that propelled Faustian culture, but it just isn't true, and it was natural sciences that informed us of this, not a theologian. Even for St. Francis of Assisi, the best he could do was demand a wolf become a city-dwelling dog.
It's not difficult to find other examples where "visceral", evolutionary realities have always informed meaning and not the other way around, so I don't agree with this at all. Sexual roles/relationships and "pair bonding", kin selection, altruism, aggression, etc. A better argument would be that they are two sides of the same coin, which is the take you see the most in our culture downstream of the Anglo-American tradition. I'm really not even sure if Heidegger would agree with this, as Dasein concerns itself with visceral experiences.
Moreover, is your millenarian religion just a kind of biocentric fascism/social darwinism?
https://gildhelm.substack.com/p/ernst-haeckels-religion-of-evolution
It is as I feared then. The amalgamation of monistic mystics is what brought modernity to the scene. Rather confused by this article. It talks about this ontology not being a kind of pretty or glorified atheism, but it reduces mind to physical elements, denies things like volition, and supposes no liberation from the world, no real ethical reality aside from serving the will of “nature”(?).
It’s also odd that you mention non-duality, buddhism and platonism when these philosophies by and large qualify reality as immaterial and abstract, materiality or matter being a property or illusionary capacity of the spirit or ethereal. They are saying that the world is actually exclusively supernatural, and that nature is a reflective or accidental element. That is a radical departure from saying the world is material and that there is a kind of vital life force to things which is still inanimate, and that there’s no capacity for transcendence or victory over the world.
I think that this is rather confusing because I don’t see classical theism and atheism, or materialism and theism synthesized, more like materialism given enchantment. I have no idea how this will be a formative element of the new world religions or paganism considering that this sort of thing is already status quo for the intellectual powers that be, and has been for some time. Is there any kind of soteriological elements to this philosophy? And kind of proper view about what one is to do? I’m just not sure what a bunch of material facts have to do with religion, even if they’re considered eternal or are afforded an infinite return.
The things you're asking for are almost exclusively Christian in nature. Paganism is phenomenological. It is as it appears to a specific people, or rather a specific ecology. So no, it's not going to have soteriology or "liberation" - there's nothing to be saved from. There's no universal code of conduct - its not a universalist worldview.
Generally you seem to believe that meaning, "religion" has to be a set of metaphysical constructions, independent and superlative of nature. I'm saying that this distinction isn't necessary, and that the ordering is wrong. Observation precedes any and all rationalization. You have to first see red before you can internalize some emotional understanding of what red means. Again, you already DO this for virtually all of your sensibilities. Values of marriage, family, etc are all fundamentally rooted in nature, not because of a tandem orderly-reasoned-divine-nature, but because these things are quite literally intrinsic to our biological existence.
Paganism is, additionally, an experiential religion. As opposed to Revelation. It takes in its immediate surroundings, its conditions, and its relationships and develops its rituals, pantheons, and myths from here. You are correct in stating that the order is reversed, but only in relationship to Christianity. It's not paganism that is the inversion of the natural religiosity of man, it's not monism that has brought "modernity".
The point of this wasn't really to deal with specific arguments, as there's plenty of people making plenty of content against things like IC already. I'm dealing more with the general idea of macroevolution (the pejorative) here.
I don't agree that IC is the main argument against it anyways, because baraminology rarely differentiates its "kinds" based on IC, but reproductive barriers. I don't think Meyer would propose a string of IC proteins so separate cats from dogs - he's more worried about bacteria. Again, plenty of content there already.
By reconcile I mean explain. There are plenty of people who try to use science to explain miracles (see Turin Shroud "radioactive blast"). That very subversion of the order Christianity sought to maintain between it and science is really the point of this article.
Dawg nobody thinks Jack Horner is some kind of “fool”
I believe the current main argument against macroevolution is time - any proposed mechanism has tested to be magnitudes too slow to reflect any agreed upon timeline. As in any mutation fixation rate as proposed by neodarwinists would take 100x the time that anyone even supposes the earth was around for.
Secondly I think reconciling Christendom with science is easy. I believe human technology is just barely beginning to approach the things Christ did, which he said would happen. Simple cataract surgery can restore sight to the blind and current developments for sensors for the never-sighted are sound. Restoring rotted flesh is gonna be just a few jumps in paradigms away. And so on.
The time problem as you've described is mentioned at the tail end of the article. Hidden away somewhat, but I did go over Behe/Snoke and Lynch's reply
No idea who that is or what "biophotons" means but I would've killed him too
Interesting. You might like this article.
https://open.substack.com/pub/biofield/p/living-organisms-stop-emitting-light?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=15lwnu